Skip to main content

The Journal Gazette

  • FILE

Thursday, January 04, 2018 1:00 am

General assembly

Child services problems put parties at odds

DCS review likely to outlast session

NIKI KELLY | The Journal Gazette

INDIANAPOLIS – Republican legislative leaders said Wednesday they will defer action regarding the embattled Department of Child Services agency until a third-party review is finished through the governor's office.

This means lawmakers will almost certainly leave town without taking any action on DCS, despite former Director Mary Beth Bonaventura's resignation weeks ago over administrative moves to save money that she said “all but ensure children will die.”

Democrats are pushing for hearings now as part of the legislative session that opened Wednesday and runs until March 14.

“We have a duty to know before we leave this session: Are the children of this state being adequately protected or not?” said Senate Democratic Leader Tim Lanane of Anderson.

But GOP Senate President Pro Tem David Long of Fort Wayne said the legislature is not equipped to hold hearings and make effective decisions about DCS. He also defended Gov. Eric Holcomb by pointing out he inherited the problem of growing caseloads at the agency and has added hundreds of millions in extra funding to its budget.

“This is a critically important topic for our state,” Long said.

Moments before, Rep. Matt Lehman, R-Berne, addressed the issue in the House, using the same talking points Long did, which were discussed Wednesday morning in a meeting between Holcomb, Long and House Speaker Brian Bosma.

Lehman said Indiana has 29,394 children in the child protective system and is an outlier compared with other states. For instance, Illinois has twice the population but half as many abused and neglected children in its system.

He agreed the department's policies and procedures – not just funding – need to be analyzed from top to bottom, and said that's what Holcomb is doing. One of Bonaventura's complaints was that administrative decisions to try to slow the growth of spending in the agency is putting kids at risk.

Since Bonaventura's bombshell, the governor has hired the nonprofit Child Welfare Policy and Practice Group to do a comprehensive department review – as it has in other states.

But that analysis isn't expected to be done before the end of the legislative session. Instead, Long and Bosma want the Legislative Council – made up of two Republicans and two Democrats – to review the report publicly when it's finalized and consider any future action.

Long said he respects Bonavenutura greatly but disagreed with the public release of her resignation letter, which listed her concerns.

He said it's important that the state review whether money is being spent effectively and efficiently, but he said it's also crucial that the state let caseworkers do their job to protect children.

Holcomb has appointed Terry Stigdon as the next director of the Indiana Department of Child Services. Stigdon currently serves as clinical director of operations at Riley Hospital for Children at IU Health in Indianapolis, and will start his new position Jan. 22.

House Democratic Leader Terry Goodin of Austin said the legislature's biennial short session used to address only emergencies but now is used regularly to address many topics. Some this year include alcohol and marijuana. But he said Republicans shouldn't cede action on DCS to the executive branch.

“This cannot stand,” Goodin said. “We have oversight powers ... what could be more dire than protecting at-risk children?”